Next Steps for Promoting Transparency in Science

April 7th, 2017, David Mellor


springer-nature


Springer Nature just added over 2,100 of their journals as signatories to the Transparency and Openness Promotion (TOP) Guidelines, published in Science in 2015. Let that sink in. 2,100 in a single shot. These important scientific guidelines now have over 2,900 signatories, including journals, publishers, societies, and funding agencies. This is a milestone in our journey to increase transparency in scientific research, our core mission. We’re thrilled and hopeful.


So… what are these guidelines and what do they accomplish?


The TOP Guidelines  are a set of eight standards that journals can use to increase clarity into the process of science. For example, journals can specify policies on data or code sharing, use of reporting guidelines, or preregistration of research. The goal is to make it easier for future scholars to understand and build on the findings.


By adding their journals to the list, signatories like Springer Nature are saying they get it. They are indicating their support for the principle of incentivizing increased transparency into the process of science, and encouraging affiliated journals to review and implement the guidelines that are appropriate for their community. Any or all of the standards can be used, and each is tiered into three levels of increasing rigor in order to reduce barriers to adoption while still providing guidance for future improvement.


However, we will not reach our mission of increasing rigor in science if we stop with a long list of signatories.


The benefits to the scientific community will come through ongoing work to integrate these practices into the normal publishing workflow. Individual researchers benefit from implementing the TOP Guidelines because it is faster and easier to follow standardized policies. The first time any given author is asked to disclose whether or not they will share data or preregister a study is novel and unexpected. They have to weigh the ethical implications and effort of sharing data against the societal benefits of doing so. They have to read up on preregistration and how it can fit in their workflow. The more it happens, the easier it gets; the efficiency gained from widespread adoption will be substantial.


As individual researchers gain experience with these policies across different journals, they will begin to see real improvements to scientific inquiry. More frequent data sharing will move science forward as researchers will use that data for new discoveries or views into thorny problems. Preregistration will make the distinction between discovery and confirmation more clear and dependable.


Recent Blogs

The Content of Open Science

What Second Graders Can Teach Us About Open Science

What's Going on With Reproducibility?

Open Science and the Marketplace of Ideas

3 Things Societies Can Do to Promote Research Integrity

How to Manage and Share Your Open Data

Interview with Prereg Challenge Award Winner Dr. Allison Skinner

Next Steps for Promoting Transparency in Science

Public Goods Infrastructure for Preprints and Innovation in Scholarly Communication

A How-To Guide to Improving the Clarity and Continuity of Your Preregistration

Building a Central Service for Preprints

Three More Reasons to Take the Preregistration Challenge

The Center for Open Science is a Culture Change Technology Company

Preregistration: A Plan, Not a Prison

How can we improve diversity and inclusion in the open science movement?

OSF Fedora Integration, Aussie style!

Replicating a challenging study: it's all about sharing the details.

How Preregistration Helped Improve Our Research: An Interview with Preregistration Challenge Awardees

Some Examples of Publishing the Research That Actually Happened

Are reproducibility and open science starting to matter in tenure and promotion review?

The IRIS Replication Award and Collaboration in the Second Language Research Community

We Should Redefine Statistical Significance

Some Cool New OSF Features

How Open Source Research Tools Can Help Institutions Keep it Simple

OSF Add-ons Help You Maximize Research Data Storage and Accessibility

10 Tips for Making a Great Preregistration

Community-Driven Science: An Interview With EarthArXiv Founders Chris Jackson, Tom Narock and Bruce Caron

A Preregistration Coaching Network

Why are we working so hard to open up science? A personal story.

One Preregistration to Rule Them All?

Using the wiki just got better.

Transparent Definitions and Community Signals: Growth in the Open Science Community

We're Committed to GDPR. Here's How.

Preprints: The What, The Why, The How.

The Prereg Challenge Is Ending. What's Next?

We are Now Registering Preprint DOIs with Crossref

Using OSF in the Lab

Psychology's New Normal

How Open Commenting on Preprints Can Increase Scientific Transparency: An Interview With the Directors of PsyArxiv, SocArxiv, and Marxiv

The Landscape of Open Data Policies

Open Science is a Behavior.

Why pre-registration might be better for your career and well-being

Interview: Randy McCarthy discusses his experiences with publishing his first Registered Report

Towards minimal reporting standards for life scientists

Looking Back on the Prereg Challenge and Forward To More Credible Research

OSF: Origin, growth, and what’s next

A Critique of the Many Labs Projects

The Rise of Open Science in Psychology, A Preliminary Report

Strategy for Culture Change

New OSF Registries Enhancements Improve Efficiency and Quality of Registrations

Registered Reports and PhD’s – What? Why? How? An Interview with Chris Chambers

How to Collaborate with Industry Using Open Science

How to Build an Open Science Network in Your Community

Seven Reasons to Work Reproducibly

COS Collaborates with Case Medical Research to Support Free Video Publishing for Clinicians and Researchers

This website relies on cookies to help provide a better user experience. By clicking Accept or continuing to use the site, you agree. For more information, see our Privacy Policy and information on cookie use.